Lecture 4

LECTURE NO. 4 (1st Edition): Is Naye Concept Ke Mutabik Prescription Kaise Karein

Ab tak pichhle lectures mein humne yeh seekha hai ki ek remedy se kya expect kiya jata hai aur kaise pata lagaya jata hai ki di hui remedy sahi tarah kaam kar rahi hai ya nahi.

Ek remedy ko apni similarity ka saboot dena chahiye. Yeh saboot tab milta hai jab remedy body ke andar se kuch bahar ki taraf nikalna shuru kare.Yani:

Centre se Periphery ki taraf (Within Outwards)

Aur disease ki jo current imbalance wali state hai use uske aane ke reverse order mein door kare.Hamari koshish disease ko Centre se Periphery ki taraf le jane ki hai.Isliye hamara target bhi Centre hi hoga.Aur hamara sabse aham kaam hoga: Centre ko Capture Karna Author ke mutabik Centre se murad:Mind hai.(Centre par asal mein kya hota hai, attack hota hai, stimulate hota hai, ya kuch aur, iska scientific explanation author apni badi kitab mein baad mein dene wale hain.)Jab Centre Mind hai to poori Repertory mein se hume sirf woh Rubrics leni hain jo Mind se related hain.

Author ke mutabik is kaam ke liye sabse behtar Repertory:Kent’s Repertory hai.Kyunki Dr. Kent ne jis tarah usko arrange kiya hai woh sabse zyada Natural aur Scientific lagta hai.

Author yahan Dr. Kent ki vision ki tareef karte hain.Unke mutabik Kent ka Repertory kisi accident ya ittefaq se us order mein nahi bana.Balke uske peeche gehri planning aur scientific soch thi.Kent ne jo order rakha woh tha:

• 1. Mind
• 2. Body
• 3. Head se neeche Yani:Within Outwards Above Downwards

Author ke mutabik yeh Natural isliye hai kyunki Nature mein growth ka order bhi isi tarah hota hai.

Sabse pehle Head banta hai.Head mein Mind ka container aur Nervous System hota hai.Uske baad body ke baaki hisse develop hote hain.

Yeh Scientific bhi hai kyunki existence aur growth mein sabse pehle Nervous System ki ahmiyat hoti hai.Uske baad baaki organs aur systems aate hain.

Author ka maanna hai ki Nature ka har order kisi na kisi Physical Law ke under kaam karta hai.

Koi bhi cheez:

• Maujood nahi reh sakti
• Grow nahi kar sakti
• Kaam nahi kar sakti

jab tak uske peeche koi Physical Law na ho.

Kaunsa law is subject ko govern karta hai, author uski tafseel apni future book mein denge.-

Rubrics Ko Samajhna Aur Patient Ki Baat Ko Rubric Mein Convert Karna

Kent ki genius ki ek aur khaas baat thi:

Alphabetical Arrangement : Yani Rubrics ko alphabetical order mein arrange karna.Isse kisi bhi rubric ko dhoondhna bahut aasaan ho jata hai.Lekin sirf alphabetical arrangement hi Kent ki khasiyat nahi thi.Asal kamaal yeh tha ki unhone Human Mind ke mukhtalif shades aur states ko bahut exact aur clear boundaries ke saath define kiya.

Us zamane mein jo bhi literature aur books available thi unka gehra mutala karne ke baad Kent ne yeh tay kiya:

Kaun se symptoms sirf Mind section mein aayenge.Aur kaun se symptoms body ke doosre sections mein rakhe jayenge.

Unka classification unki Mind ki definition par dependend tha.Kent ke mutabik Mind do faculties par mushtamil hai:

• 1. Will
• 2. Understanding

Author ke nazdeek Mind ki anatomy ko samjhane ke liye yeh sabse reasonable explanation hai.—Ab hum lecture ke asal maqsad yani Prescription ki taraf wapas aate hain.

Sabse pehla aur sabse aham kaam hai:Present Ailment Se Related Predominating Symptoms Ko Pehchanna Yeh zaroori hai kyunki hume disease ko reverse order mein le jana hai.

Uske baad agla bahut important kaam hai:Repertory Ki Madad Se Similar Remedy Select Karna ; Repertory mein jo Rubrics hote hain unke meanings aur senses bahut exact hote hain.Lekin patient se jo symptoms milte hain woh aam zabaan mein hote hain.Chahe woh subjective hon ya objective.Patient apni halat ko apne alfaaz mein bayan karta hai.

Doctor ka asli hunar yeh hai ki:Patient ke crude expressions ko sahi rubric mein fit kare.Author kehta hai:Rubrics ko fixed dies samjho.Aur patient ke expressions ko raw material samjho.Pehle raw material ko sort karo.Phir usko sahi rubric mein fit karo.Uske baad hi sahi remedy tak pahunch sakte ho.—Iske Liye Rubrics Ki Gehri Samajh Zaroori HaiSirf naam ya dictionary meaning jaanna kaafi nahi.Rubric ka exact sense samajhna zaroori hai.

Misal ke taur par:

WEEPINGAur uske neeche yeh rubrics:

• WEEPING, causeless
• WEEPING, without knowing why
• WEEPING, involuntary

Zahir mein tino ek jaise lagte hain.Lekin asal mein tino ke meanings alag hain.

• WEEPING, CAUSELESS : Agar patient se poocha jaye:”Tum kyun ro rahe ho?”Aur woh kahe:”Mujhe nahi pata.”To yeh Weeping Causeless hai.Usko sabab maloom hi nahi.—
• WEEPING, WITHOUT KNOWING WHY : Yahan patient khud bhi hairan hota hai.Woh sochta hai:”Main kyun ro raha hoon?”Usko curiosity hoti hai.Lekin jawab nahi milta.Yani woh reason dhoondh raha hai magar samajh nahi pa raha.
• WEEPING, INVOLUNTARY : Yahan patient rona nahi chahta.Khud ko rokne ki koshish karta hai.Lekin control nahi kar pata. Aansoo khud-ba-khud nikalte rehte hain.Jaise pani ka behne wala nala.

Isi tarah doctor ko un rubrics ke meanings aur differences bhi samajhne chahiye jo dekhne mein ek jaise lagte hain.

Misal ke taur par:

• Anxiety
• Anguish
• Fear
• Restlessness
• Excitement

• ANXIETY : Kisi doubtful cheez ki wajah se paida hone wali bechaini.Yani kuch hoga ya nahi hoga, is uncertainty ki bechaini.—
• ANGUISH : General mental aur physical takleef.Ek overall distress.–
• FEAR : Aane wale kisi specific waqea ya cheez ka darr.Yani future mein kuch hone wala hai aur uska khauf.
• RESTLESSNESS: Khoya hua comfort wapas paane ki koshish.Bechain rehna taaki sukoon mil sake.
• EXCITEMENT : Kisi provocation ya stimulation ke baad uncomfortable ho jana.

Cross References Ki Ahmiyat

Ab author kuch aur rubrics ka group deta hai:

• Hatred
• Aversion
• Loathing
• Disgust

Pehli nazar mein lagta hai ke sabka matlab sirf: Dislike hai.Lekin gehra dekho to sab alag alag meanings rakhte hain.

• HATRED : Kisi shakhs ya cheez ko dekhte hi foran reject kar dena.Turant opposition. Seedha:”NO”Yani resistance. No entry.
• AVERSION : Yahan pehle liking thi.Ab woh dislike mein badal gayi.Koi khaas wajah nahi.Bas taste badal gaya.Pehle pasand tha.Ab pasand nahi.Agar poochho kyun?To patient ke paas koi wazeh jawab nahi hota.Sirf itna kehta hai:”Mujhe pasand nahi.”
• LOATHING : Yahan dislike ka matlab hai:Interest ka khatam ho jana.Misal ke taur par:Life mein dilchaspi khatam ho jana.Disappointment ki wajah se.Patient kehta hai:”Ab jeene ke liye bacha hi kya hai?”Yani life ki charm khatam ho gayi.
• DISGUST : Yahan liking apni had tak pahunch chuki hoti hai.Uske baad aur zyada bardasht nahi hota.Ab rejection shuru ho jata hai.Jaise aadmi itna bhar jaye ke nausea shuru ho jaye.Aur agar aur diya jaye to ulti ho sakti hai.
  • Example :Patient kehta hai:”Doctor sahab, main aapka treatment lete lete thak gaya hoon. Ab koi fayda nazar nahi aa raha.”Yahan woh treatment se disgust feel kar raha hai.Yani aur accept karne ko tayyar nahi.

Agar aap is method ke mutabik prescribe karna chahte hain to Rubrics ko sirf dictionary ke meanings se mat samjho.

Rubrics ko:Mathematical Equations ki tarah exact samjho.Jaise:

4 = 1+1+1+1

4 = 2+2

4 = 3+1

4 = 8−4

Sabka result 4 hai.Lekin expression alag alag hai.

Bilkul isi tarah:Patient ki expressions alag ho sakti hain.Lekin rubric ek hi ho sakta hai.

Author kehta hai ki patient ki expressions ko Rubrics mein convert karte waqt yeh yaad rakho:

Rubric ek ho sakta hai,lekin patient usko bayan karne ke tareeqe bahut alag alag rakh sakta hai.Isi baat ko samjhane ke liye author Kent ke ek rubric ka example deta hai:DISTURBED, AVERSE TO BEINGIs rubric ka asal matlab samajhna zaroori hai.Jab koi aadmi apni current position, arrangement ya condition mein theek ho aur usmein kisi tarah ki tabdeeli pasand na kare, to usko kaha ja sakta hai:

Disturbed, Averse to Being :Woh disturbance pasand nahi karta.Usko apni present state mein rehna pasand hai.—Yeh disturbance tab hoti hai jab:Koi doosra uski present state ko badalne ki koshish kare.Lekin agar woh khud apni marzi se position change kare to usko disturbance mehsoos nahi hoti.Kyunki usne khud decide kiya hai.—Kabhi kabhi severe aggravation ke dauran patient ek position mein sukoon mehsoos karta hai.Jab aggravation kam hoti hai to woh khud position change kar leta hai.Lekin agar usko zabardasti move karaya jaye to woh disturb ho jata hai.-

EXAMPLE NO. 1

Ek aadmi duty par hai.Usne apna kaam is tarah arrange kiya hai ke woh ek fixed time mein complete ho jaye. Achaanak usko kaha jata hai:Yeh kaam chhodo.Naya kaam shuru karo.Kaam aur badha lo.Ya poora arrangement badal do.

Uski foran reaction hogi:Na-pasandgi aur resistance.

Kyun?

Kyunki woh disturb ho raha hai.

EXAMPLE NO. 2

Ek aadmi aaram se kursi par baitha hua hai.Achaanak usko uthne ko kaha jata hai.Woh irritate ho jata hai.Kyun?Kyunki uski present comfort disturb hui.Yeh bhi:DISTURBED, AVERSE TO BEINGhai.

EXAMPLE NO. 3

Koi patient kisi physical ya mental takleef se guzar raha hai.Apne aap ko relief dene ke liye:Chup pada haiSo raha haiYa aaram kar raha haiAb agar koi usse baat karna shuru kar de.Ya usko disturb kare.To woh bardasht nahi karega.Kyunki uski present state toot rahi hai.Yeh bhi:DISTURBED, AVERSE TO BEINGke andar aata hai.

Jab Do Rubrics Ek Jaise Lagte Hain

Kabhi kabhi do ya zyada rubrics ek doosre ke muqable mein nazar aati hain.Aur doctor confuse ho sakta hai.

ADMONITION, AGGRAVATES :

Admonition ka matlab hai:Daantna , Samjhana , Warning dena , Advice dena , Tokna Aksar yeh sab kisi well-wisher ki taraf se hota hai.

Jaise:Maa-baap , Dost , Elder—Agar kisi ko daanta jaye aur woh foran react kare:”Kaun ho tum mujhe yeh sab kehne wale?””Main khud apna khayal rakh sakta hoon.”

To yeh:ADMONITION, AGGRAVATES hai.Lekin agar reaction foran na aaye.Aur baar baar tokne ke baad aaye.To phir asal problem admonition nahi hai.Balke:

DISTURBANCE hai.Yani usko repeatedly disturb kiya ja raha hai.Isliye woh react kar raha hai.Aise case mein rubric:

DISTURBED, AVERSE TO BEING zyada sahi ho sakta hai.

Case example of Housewife

Ek aurat khud bimar hai.Phir bhi khana paka rahi hai.Usko fikr hai ki ghar walon ko takleef na ho.Khana tayyar karne ke baad woh dekhna chahti hai ke sab log uska banaya hua khana kha lein.Ab agar ghar ka koi member khana na khaye.To woh bahut gussa ho jati hai.Yeh isliye nahi ke khana waste hua.Balke isliye ke uski mehnat ki qadar nahi hui.Usko lagta hai uski marzi ke khilaf baat hui.Aur yeh baat usko disturb karti hai.

Case Example

Pt :Mujhe neend chahiye.

Dr :Dard ka kya?

Pt : mujhe lagta hai neend hi usko relief degi.

Yaha Dard asal problem nahi.

Problem yeh hai ke dard uski neend disturb kar raha hai.

Isliye woh pain killer nahi maangta.Balke sleeping pill maangta hai.

Yahan doctor galti se usko:

• FEAR, SUFFERING OF
• DELIRIUM, crying help for
• ESCAPE, attempts to

mein daal sakta hai.

Lekin asal mein yeh:

DISTURBED, AVERSE TO BEING ka case ho sakta hai.

FEAR, SUFFERING OF : Ab author doosra important rubric samjhata hai:FEAR, SUFFERING OF Yani:Takleef ka darr—

Example 1:

Pt : Jo marzi kar lo, lekin mujhe aur dard mat do.

Ya

Pt : Main phir nahi aaoonga agar mujhe aur dard hua

Yahan woh khud maan raha hai ke usko dard ka darr hai.Yeh:FEAR, SUFFERING OF hai.

Example 2

Patient pain mein hai.Baat karne se pain badhta hai.Isliye chup rehta hai.Yeh zaroori nahi ke:

• ANSWER, aversion to
• TALKING, complaints agg.

Ho sakta hai woh sirf:FEAR, SUFFERING OF ho.Kyunki usko dard badhne ka darr hai.-

Example 3

Mouth ulcer wala patient.Khana khane se dard hota hai.Isliye khana nahi khata.

Dr :Kyun nahi kha rahe?

Pt :Dard se darr lagta hai.To yeh:FEAR, SUFFERING OF hai.Na ke:EAT, refuses to.

Example 4

Malaria patient.Usko pehle severe rigors aur bone-breaking pains ho chuke hain.

Agla attack aane se pehle hi woh doctor ko kehta hai:”Bas woh dard mat aane dena.””Fever aa jaye to bhi chalega.”Yahan woh future suffering se darr raha hai.Yeh:FEAR, SUFFERING OF hai.Na ke:

• ANTICIPATION, complaints from
• CAUTIOUS
• IMPATIENCE, pains from-l

Sabse Important Differentiation Kabhi patient khud kehta hai:”Haan doctor sahab, mujhe dard ka darr hai.”Lekin author kehta hai:Har baar patient ki baat ko seedha accept mat karo. Kabhi kabhi patient apni halat ka sahi analysis nahi kar pata.—Asal Fear mein:Takleef hone se pehle hi mental discomfort hota hai.—Lekin agar discomfort sirf tab ho jab usko apni comfortable state change karni pade:To woh Fear nahi.Balke:DISTURBED, AVERSE TO BEING hai.-

Example :Mouth ulcer patient.Woh chup pada hai.Movement avoid kar raha hai.Baat nahi kar raha.Kyun?Kyunki usko apni current comfortable position maintain rakhni hai.Woh disturbance nahi chahta.—Yahan asal issue:Fear nahi balke Disturbance se aversion hai.—Author ke mutabik isi jagah doctors aksar galti karte hain.Aur:Bryonia prescribe kar dete hain.Jabki case asal mein:Gelsemium ka hota hai.

Kyunki:Gelsemium mein bhi disturbance se aversion hoti hai.Lekin:Fear of suffering maujood nahi hoti.—Yahi fine differentiation sahi remedy tak pahunchne mein madad karti hai.—

Present, Predominating Aur Persisting Symptoms Ki Ahmiyat

Ab author is lecture ka sabse important point bayan karta hai.

Woh kehta hai:Prescription ke liye patient ke tamam symptoms ko consider nahi karna.Yani jo kuch patient ek waqt mein bata raha hai us sab ko ikattha karke prescription nahi karni.Balke poore symptoms mein se sirf woh symptoms chunne hain jo:

• Present
• Predominating
• Persisting ho.

Aur yeh symptoms patient ki present complaint se directly related hone chahiye.

Aam taur par in rubrics ki tadaad:3 se kam nahi honi chahiye.Lekin agar koi rubric bahut hi strong aur overwhelming ho aur kisi ek remedy ko bahut clear indicate karti ho to exception ho sakta hai.

Author phir yaad dilata hai ki humara maqsad:

Disease ko reverse order mein le jana hai.Aur reverse order establish karne ke liye hume sabse pehle:

Present state ko samajhna padega.

Patient apni baaton, actions aur behaviour ke zariye hume jo symptoms dikhata hai, woh asal mein disease ki sabse upar wali layer hoti hai.

Yahi current layer hamare liye important hai.

Permanent Nature Ko Ignore Karna Author ek bahut important baat kehta hai.Mumkin hai patient bachpan se:

• Kisi khas temperament ka ho
• Kuch habits rakhta ho
• Kuch emotions rakhta ho
• Kuch peculiar traits rakhta ho
• Aur yeh sab ab bhi uski personality ka hissa hon.

Lekin prescription ke waqt hume in sab cheezon se mutasir nahi hona chahiye.

Doctor ko bilkul fresh aur unbiased mind ke saath case dekhna chahiye.

Patient hamare paas kyun aata hai?

Kyunki usko koi:

Physical problem mehsoos hui hai.

Aur woh us problem se nijaat chahta hai.

Ab us physical disease ka ek asar uske Mind par pada hoga.

Doctor ka kaam hai:Usi mental state ko identify karna jo present ailment ki wajah se paida hui hai.—Yeh mental state:Purani bhi ho sakti hai. Nai bhi ho sakti hai. Lekin sabse important baat yeh hai:Woh is waqt Present honi chahiye.Purani hai ya nai, is se farq nahi padta.—Isliye author kehta hai:Patient ki asal problem us waqt uski physical complaint hai.Aur hume us complaint ka reflection Mind mein dhoondhna hai.—Author isko ek misaal se samjhata hai.Woh kehta hai:Disease ki current station ko identify karna mushkil nahi hona chahiye.Bas us station par pahunch kar woh train pakadni hai jo reverse direction mein chalti hai.Yani:Present se Past ki taraf.

Author yeh bhi kehta hai ke yeh art bina mehnat ke hasil nahi hota.Jaise koi sadhu ya devotee lagataar mehnat aur yaqeen ke saath Siddhi hasil karta hai.Waise hi Homeopath ko bhi:

• Mazboot yaqeen
• Lagataar mehnat
• Musalsal practice ki zarurat hoti hai.

Tab ja kar perception develop hota hai.Aur phir success milni shuru hoti hai.

Practical Example No. 1

Maan lijiye ek patient bachpan se in mizaji traits ka malik hai:

• 1. ANTICIPATION, complaints from
• 2. REST, when things are not in proper place, cannot
• 3. CENSORIOUS
• 4. COMPLAINING, supposed injury, of
• 5. LAMENTING, sickness, about his
• 6. SUICIDAL disposition
• 7. DEATH desires
• 8. QUARRELSOME
• 9. GRIEF, hunting for something to grieve oneself
• 10. DISCONTENTED
• 11. CONTEMPTUOUS

Yeh sab uski permanent personality ka hissa ho sakte hain.Lekin author kehta hai:Hume in sab se koi matlab nahi.

Aaj patient ko:Stomach pain Headache Ya asthma attack hua hai.Ab dekhna yeh hai ki is present disease ka uske mind par kya asar pada hai.—Maan lijiye present mental state yeh hai:

• No. 1 : Usko lagta hai jaise disease ne usko gher liya hai.Woh jaldi se jaldi is halat se nikalna chahta hai.Usko lagta hai:”2–3 din theek hai, lekin main zyada der bardasht nahi kar sakta.”Woh bore aur tang aa raha hai.
• No. 2 : Dard ki wajah se ro raha hai.
• No. 3 : Chilla raha hai:”Doctor kuch karo.””Meri madad karo.”
• No. 4 : Attack ke baad sochta hai:Yeh dard phir aa gaya to?Aur apni health ke future ko lekar pareshan hota hai.-
• Ab in expressions ko rubrics mein convert karte hain.
  • No. 1 : ENNUI
  • No. 2 : WEEPING, pains with
  • No. 3 : SHRIEKING, aid for
  • No. 4 : EMBARRASSED, ailments after

In sab rubrics ka common remedy:PLATINUM nikalta hai

Practical Example No. 2

Ab isi patient ko kisi aur waqt dekhiye.Us waqt uski mental state alag hai.–

• No. 1 : Doctor bulao. Mujhe koi dawa do.Khud treatment suggest karta hai.Kabhi dawa ka naam bhi batata hai.Semi-delirious ya delirious andaaz mein baat karta hai.
• No. 2 : Kabhi itna bimar nahi hua.Pata nahi mujhe kya ho gaya.Dusron se poochta hai:Tum batao mujhe kya hua hai?
• No.3 : Sab ne khana kha liya?Arre main to khana banana bhool gaya.Mere hote hue ghar wale bhooke nahi rehne chahiye.

Ab in expressions ke rubrics:

• 1. DELIRIUM, crying help for
• 2. ANXIETY, hypochondriacal
• 3. BUSINESS, talks of

In sab ko cover karne wali remedy:CANTHARIS hai.

Practical Example No. 3

Ek aur set of symptoms:

• No.1 : Patient ko lagta hai ke woh kaam karne ke qabil nahi raha.Business aur duty handle nahi kar sakta.Efficiency kam ho gayi hai.—
• No.2 : Khud ko malamat karta hai.Kehta hai:”Main apna farz poora nahi kar pa raha.”
• No.3 : Kabhi bahut discouraged hota hai.Kabhi haughty ho jata hai.

Rubrics:

• 1. BUSINESS, incapacity for
• 2. CONTEMPTUOUS, of self
• 3. DISCOURAGED, alternating with haughtiness
• Common remedy:AGNUS CASTUS—Is Sab Ka Asal Maqsad
• Author kehta hai:Dekho kitna farq hai:Ek taraf patient ki permanent personality.Aur doosri taraf uski current disease se paida hui mental state.

Revolutionized Homeopathy mein importance:

Permanent nature ko nahi balke Present, Predominating, Persisting Mental State kodi jati hai.—Kyunki disease ki current layer wahi hai.

Aur reverse order wahi se shuru hoga.

Author ke mutabik isi tareeqe se selected remedy:Seedha diseased organ tak pahunchti hai.

Disease ko reverse order mein chalati hai.

Within outward movement establish karti hai.

Above downward movement establish karti hai.

Aur body ke kisi outlet se discharge shuru kar sakti hai.

Jo healing process ka hissa mana jata hai.—Lecture ke end mein author maanta hai ki yeh method bilkul naya hai.Isliye naye logon ko shuru mein mushkil lag sakta hai.Lekin thodi mehnat, sabr aur practice ke baad isko samajhna aasaan ho jata hai.

Author yeh bhi kehta hai ki jo doctors kaafi arse se unke contact mein hain aur unki lectures attend karte rahe hain, woh is method ko successful tareeqe se practice kar rahe hain.

Aur isi wajah se unke students un par pressure daal rahe hain ke ek regular institute shuru kiya jaye jahan is approach ki theoretical aur practical training di ja sake.